Representation & Interaction Design: Journal

Entries categorized as ‘Dust/Magic-Class’

Lisa Guernsey: Children’s Perceptions of Visual Media

October 12, 2007 · Leave a Comment

This is the major question for children so young when confronted with all the tools and artifacts of our heavily visual culture: how do young children, even infants perceive visual media??? There’s a lot of interesting research on image perception and young childrenthat Lisa Guernsey looks at that break down the factors at play.

So, at a very basic level of the perceptual organs involved, do little children “see” the same way adults do? Lisa Guernsey notes the sensory organs of infants are just developing and so it is hard to truly know what a 10 month old “sees” and in fact at that age, they can’t focus the same way adults can on images. So what they “see” as infants are probably more imagistic and blurry, not sharply focused.

Lisa also points out Judy DeLoache’s research on “insensitivity to picture orientation” which is pretty typical until age 2 1/2. So a 2 year old can look at upside-down pictures and perceive them just as well as right side up pictures.

The research on how and what infants see is perhaps particularly hampered by how much research can be done with infants as subjects. Anyway, vis the research about what IS known about how children perceive visual images, Guernsey asks: what does it mean to expose such young children to visual media on a screen (video, TV) —is it doing any good or doing any harm? How can we shape their exposure, which is almost unavoidable given the social and commercial phenomena of visual media directed towards and consumed by infants and young children?

This is for me the “message” or one of the messages of Lisa’s book- that all this visual media (and now, “interactive” media) is here to stay, and so what we should be doing is making the best kind of choices around how we and our kids engage with it.

Categories: Dust/Magic-Class

Guernsey: When Do Children Start Thinking in Symbols?…

October 12, 2007 · Leave a Comment

Lisa Guernsey (book: Into the Minds of Babes, 2007) reviews the research and discussion around issues of young children (infants to around 5- 7 years old) and television/video media.

In Chapt. 3, she cites the research of Judy DeLoache (developmental psychologist at Univ. of Virginia) who has been researching the question of when children start thinking in symbols? Until about age 3, children tend to see objects in terms of what’s in front of them. When given a picture or video representation of the same object, they do not relate the two together. The picture is a separate object. In various studies with 2 and 2 1/2 year olds, the children were not able to view a representation as related to its referent (such as an actual room and a small scale replica model of the same room) until they were told that the two were actually the same (in the study using the rooms, the children were made convinced of the idea that the small scale model was THE ACTUAL room, only that it had gotten shrunken and that’s why it was smaller). DeLoache did similar studies comparing the 2 year olds to 3 year olds, and by 3 years old children seem to start being able to think about representations, or what DeLoache calls “dual channel” thinking.

But this is a cognitive skill that is still developing. Even 4 and 5 year olds can refer to the images they see on TV as if they are the things themselves- so that a child could wish for Mr. Rogers to come out of the TV box so they could play!

Categories: Dust/Magic-Class

For the DustorMagic Class, a PDF interview with Will Wright, creator of the Sims

September 21, 2007 · Leave a Comment

Categories: Dust/Magic-Class